Almost 15 years ago, I had bonding on my four front teeth to hide tetracycline stains. After the bonding chipped on one tooth last year, I returned to my general dentist and asked about veneers for my six front teeth.
She recommended crowns instead, explaining that they would be more durable, hide the stains better, and help with my gummy smile. She is a well-respected dentist, so I trusted her recommendation.
Now I can see a gray color beneath some of the crowns. It’s really noticeable in fluorescent light. My dentist has offered to remake the affected crowns at no cost, but my current crowns make me wonder if the results would be any different.
I am also disappointed that my teeth were so drastically prepared for crowns. Now I understand that I will always need crowns on these teeth now. My dentist did not explain that to me initially. At this point, I am considering asking for a refund and seeing a cosmetic dentist for another opinion. Is that reasonable or is it not unusual to have grayness beneath crowns on the first try? Thanks. Jaime from MI
Jaime,
Your concerns are understandable. You trusted a longtime dentist with an excellent reputation, and now you have six crowns that do not look the way you expected.
Tetracycline staining presents some of the most difficult color challenges in cosmetic dentistry. The goal is not simply to cover the dark teeth. The restorations also need to have enough translucency and color variation to look natural.
Were Crowns Necessary Instead of Veneers?

Porcelain veneers require minimal tooth preparation
Crowns may not have been the only option for covering tetracycline stains. Porcelain veneers can often mask significant discoloration while requiring less removal of healthy tooth structure, although the appropriate treatment depends on the condition of each tooth.
The difficult part is that your teeth have already been prepared for crowns. You cannot restore the tooth structure that was removed, so these teeth will continue to need full-coverage restorations.
Why Might Treating Only Six Teeth Create a Problem?
Treating six teeth may not produce a balanced result if more than six teeth show prominently when you smile. Skilled cosmetic dentists focus treatment planning on the entire smile zone rather than automatically stopping at the six front teeth.
Depending on your smile, several factors can affect the final result:
- the darkness of the untreated teeth
- the amount of tetracycline discoloration underneath the crowns
- the opacity and translucency of the porcelain
- the skill and experience of both the dentist and the dental laboratory
With a wider smile, eight, ten, or even twelve teeth may need to be considered when planning treatment.
Should You Have the Same Dentist Redo the Crowns?
Before agreeing to a redo, get a second opinion from a cosmetic dentist with significant experience treating tetracycline stains. Then determine whether remaking a few crowns will solve the overall problem. Your dentist’s willingness to remake the crowns at no charge is encouraging.
The gray showing through suggests that more attention is needed to mask the underlying color. Correcting it without creating opaque, unnatural-looking teeth takes considerable skill. Ask to see photographs of the dentist’s own tetracycline cases, especially cases involving discoloration similar to yours.
If you decide to have the work redone elsewhere, discuss a refund with your current dentist. You can still maintain your relationship with that dentist for general dental care if you are otherwise happy with the treatment you receive.
The Monroe, Louisiana, dentists at Bayou Dental Group sponsor this post. Please read how Dr. Finley and his team strive to offer some of the best dental care in Monroe.
